Annex 9 Questionnaire for the executives: example

Dear executives,

As part of its annual self-evaluation, the Board requests your structured and candid feedback on its performance, behaviours, and ways of working.

Purpose of your input

The primary purpose of this input is to help the Board improve its work by providing the executive perspective on:

  • How the Board’s actions and processes are experienced by leadership;
  • How effectively the Board supports the organization's strategy and long-term objectives;
  • How the Board could bring even more value into interaction with CEO and other executives.

It is not about the judgement, but about higher efficiency of the Board and better Board-CEO-executives interaction that will improve the whole organisation.

Call to action

Please provide open and balanced input, highlighting both strengths and areas for improvement. This process is crucial for strengthening alignment, trust, and effectiveness between the Board and executives, benefiting the entire organization.

The Board thanks you for your contribution to strengthening the organization's governance and leadership.

Questionnaire

Score each question from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest) and add your answer or comment. Open questions are answered in the last column only.

No.QuestionScore (1–5)Answer / comments
1. Board–management interaction & dynamics
1.1How effectively does the Board engage with management during meetings?
1.2How well does the Board create a constructive and respectful environment for open dialogue?
1.3How well does the Board demonstrate trust in management while still exercising appropriate oversight?
1.4How well Board discussions are focused, disciplined, and free from micromanagement?
1.5How well does the Board sufficiently take into account management’s expertise and perspectives when making decisions?
1.6How well does the Board foster an inclusive environment where all directors and executives contribute?
2. Strategic oversight & long-term focus
2.1To what extent does the Board provide clear strategic direction while allowing management to execute?
2.2To what extent does the Board focus on long-term priorities rather than operational matters?
2.3To what extent does the Board support management in addressing strategic risks and opportunities?
2.4To what extent is the Board forward-looking in terms of market trends, technology, HR/people issues, sustainability, and governance topics?
3. Quality of challenge & constructive feedback
3.1How well does the Board provide constructive strategic challenge that improves the quality of decision-making?
3.2To what extent Board members ask relevant, well-prepared, and value-adding questions?
3.3How well does the Board demonstrate that it holds management accountable in a consistent and unbiased manner?
3.4How well does the Board balance its support and challenge?
4. Communication, quality of information flow
4.1To what extent the Board’s request for information is clear, reasonable, and aligned with its governance responsibilities?
4.2To what extent the Board and/or Chairperson is clearly communicating requirements about the Board meeting materials (depth, content, details) to make them appropriate and helpful for the Board to hold efficient discussion and make required decisions?
4.3How well does the Board make efficient use of the information provided by management (presentations, KPIs, dashboards, risk reports, etc.)?
4.4In your opinion how effective is communication between the Board (or its committees) and management (i.e. clear, respectful, and open)?
4.5To what extent is the Board prepared to provide effective oversight and support during a major crisis or disruption?
5. Chairperson’s performance and value added
5.1How effective is the Chair in leading the Board and setting the agenda?
5.2To what extent division of responsibilities between the Chair (governance) and the CEO (management) is clear and respected by both parties?
5.3To what extent Chair interacts with management (outside of the CEO) in a way that supports the CEO's authority and avoids micromanagement?
5.4To what extent Chair and CEO are aligned on the company's strategic priorities, providing a stable and consistent direction for the management team?
5.5To what extent does the Chair–CEO relationship enable a balanced leadership challenge that translates Board expectations into clear direction for the CEO and management?
5.6To what extent partnership between the Chair and CEO demonstrates a high degree of mutual respect and trust?
5.7To what extent does the relationship between the Chair and CEO contribute positively to the overall tone and culture of the company?
5.8What is one specific area where improved collaboration or clarity between the Chair and CEO would most enhance management team effectiveness?
5.9Are there any instances where you believe the Chair-CEO dynamic has negatively affected management's ability to execute strategy? (Please describe without naming individuals.)
6. Board processes & meeting effectiveness
6.1To what extent are the Board meetings well-structured to enable effective discussion and decisions?
6.2How well does the Board allocate sufficient time to strategic items vs. administrative or operational issues?
6.3To what extent decisions are made in a timely and decisive manner, they are not postponed?
6.4How well does the Board follow up on decisions and action items clearly and consistently?
6.5How well does the Board demonstrate strong internal discipline (preparation, agenda discipline, confidentiality, etc.)?
7. Competence, composition & skills of the Board
7.1To what extent does the Board have the right mix of competencies required for current and future challenges?
7.2How well do Board members demonstrate adequate understanding of the company’s business and industry?
7.3How do you feel to what extent the Board is open to external perspectives and continuous learning?
8. Interaction with the CEO specifically
8.1How well does the Board provide the CEO with clear expectations and constructive guidance?
8.2How well does the Board support the CEO in addressing key challenges (strategy, leadership, talent, transformation, risk, etc.)?
8.3To what extent is the CEO evaluation process by the Board fair, transparent, consistent and is it creating maximum value for the CEO?
8.4How well does the Board and Chairperson support and advise the CEO to develop his competences and performance?
9. Interaction with broader management team
9.1How well do Board members show respect and professionalism in interactions with senior management?
9.2How well do Board members listen carefully to management presentations and engage meaningfully?
9.3How well does the Board provide an opportunity for management to share concerns or insights openly?
9.4To what extent the Board understands the realities of day-to-day operations without overstepping boundaries of management work?
10. Risk, compliance & governance oversight
10.1How effectively does the Board oversee risk management and internal controls?
10.2How well does the Board sufficiently consider sustainability, ESG, and reputational risks?
10.3How effectively does the Board monitor the company's engagement with its key non-shareholder stakeholders?
10.4To what extent are the processes of governance and their purposes used by the Board clear to management?
11. Board committee(s)
11.1How effective is the Board committee(s) in interacting with management?
11.2To what extent Board committee(s) requests are reasonable and aligned with its mandate?
11.3How well does the Board committee(s) operate professionally, with clear communication back to the Board and management?
12. Overall performance & suggestions
12.1What could the Board do in order to improve the value it creates even more?
12.2What behaviours or processes should the Board improve to work more effectively with management?
12.3Is there anything the Board should stop doing because it does not add value?
12.4Additional comments or suggestions.
Top